At Five Star Pens, we strive to offer quality vintage and modern pens from numerous manufacturers such as Parker, Waterman's, Conklin, Cross, Wahl Eversharp, Sheaffer's, Montblanc and more.


Sheaffer Snorkel Set, Valiant, c1956, Buckskin Tan (looks Pink) pen is 5 9/16 inches closed, both pieces are exceptionally clean, nib marked 'F5' which means Fine 14k 2-tone Triumph, pen fully restored, pencil also working w/ original eraser, restored, Exc+, $225, Item # SH457 SOLD

____________________________________


Kraker Gold Filled Floral Overlay, hand-engraved, rare and beautiful pen, c1915, 5 3/16 inches closed, while there is no maker's mark on this pen it is unmistakably a Kraker, (excerpt above taken from blue Fischler and Schneider book; George Kraker, founder of Kraker Pen Company, was a former partner of W.A. Sheaffer - note how esthetically & functionally similar this pen is to Sheaffer pens from the same era), original unpolished and unrestored condition, exceptionally clean overlay w/ no dings or dents, no brassing, hard rubber has oxidized to a dark brown, nib is Fine w/ just a faint flex, unrestored, Exc+, $750, Item # KR301  SOLD

____________________________________

Sterling Hand-Engraved Sheaffer, rare pen, c1917, 5 3/8 inches closed, unpolished, initials to cartouche, only flaw is that a small portion of the sterling rolled cap crown edge is missing just above clip (see pic); F+ nib w/ faint flex, restored, VG+, $650, Item # SH361 SOLD

____________________________________

 


Sheaffer Lifetime Balance Pen, c1935, Oversized model, 5 1/2 inches closed, nice clean gently used pen, Fine firm two-tone Lifetime nib, restored, Exc, $160, Item #SH454 SOLD

____________________________________

 

Sheaffer Lifetime Balance, 5 9/16 inches closed (1 size below oversize), c1930s, decent coloring, a fair amount of brassing to cap band, name heat- stamped on barrel (see pic), smooth Fine firm nib, nice looking pen, VG+, $100, Item # SH198 SOLD

_______________________________


Sheaffer Lifetime Black & Pearl Flattop, junior size model, 4 9/16 inches closed, c1928, clean trim, some nicks to barrel, white dot on cap crown, smooth firm Fine Lifetime nib, VG, $80, Item # SH199 SOLD

_______________________________


Sheaffer 350 Balance, c1936, brown striated, slim model, 5 7/16 inches closed, nice clean gently used condition, smooth firm Med 14k nib, restored, Exc, $60, Item # SH451 SOLD

____________________________________


Sheaffer 3-25 Flattop, c1928, 4 1/2 inches closed, smooth XF 3-25 nib, restored, VG, $50, Item # SH452 SOLD

____________________________________

 

Sheaffer BCHR #2, 1913, this is their earliest/first year imprint, 5 3/8 inches closed, clipless model, excellent chasing and color, crown of cap is marked '2', Medium early Self-Filling nib w/ med flex, nice clean Christmas box w/ some vintage writing on top & bottom, this is our first 1913 Sheaffer in 24 years (1913 was Sheaffer's first year), restored, Exc++, $350, Item # SH453 Sale Pending

_______________________________________

Sheaffer Lifetime Jade Flattop, Oversize model, 5 1/4 inches closed, c1928, user grade pen, discolored, fairly clean trim, solid reliable user, smooth firm XF Lifetime nib, Good, $95, Item # SH202  SOLD

_______________________________

Sheaffer 3-25 Flattop, c1928, 5 5/16 inches closed, see pic of cap lip crack, Med firm 46 Special nib, restored, VG, $65, Item # SH415  SOLD

____________________________________

 

Sheaffer 5-30 Balance, 5 5/16 inches closed, c1930s, a little yellowing at the threads, color is otherwise perfect, Med firm nib, Exc+, $200, Item # SH209 SOLD

_______________________________

Sheaffer Pencil, 1929, Jade, 5 1/8 inches, slim model, perfect color, one flaw - there is a small flat spot on the barrel suggesting that a name or initials were removed - can't see it but you can feel it, clean crown, no dings or dents, working, VG, $25, Item # SH437 SOLD

__________________________________

Sheaffer's Lady with Basket Base, c1920s, measures 3 1/4  x  2 1/4  x  4 inches tall, a solid heafty base weighing 1 pound, very clean piece, Exc+, $145, Item #SH408 SOLD

_________________________________________

 

Sheaffer Lifetime Desk Pen, 8 1/4 tip to tip, c1928, smooth firm Fine Lifetime nib, Exc, $50, Item # SH446 SOLD

_______________________________

Sheaffer Targa Set, c1976, solid Sterling Silver (not plate), model 1006, Made in USA, 14k Fine nib, comes w/original converter & box, both pieces working, NM, $350, Item # SH392 SOLD

______________________________

 

Sheaffer Midget Balance Pen, 3-25, c1932, 4 1/4 inches closed, clean trim except for a tiny amount of brassing to clip ball, good coloring but not perfect, Fine firm nib, restored, Exc, $175, Item # SH212 SOLD

____________________________________

Sheaffer #350, c1936, red striated, slim model, 5 7/16 inches closed, user grade pen - no cracks, no damage, no deep scratches but surface condition shows that pen was used fairly regularly, still a pretty piece that would make a good user, smooth firm Fine+ 14k #3 nib, restored, VG+, $65, Item # SH448  SOLD

____________________________________

Sheaffer Lifetime Jade Flattop, junior size model, 4 1/2 inches closed, c1928, very good color, a little brassing to the clip ball, smooth firm Med+ Lifetime nib, Exc, $80, Item # SH210 SOLD

_______________________________

Sheaffer's Balance Pencil, Green & Blk, c1934, 4 3/4 inches, humpback clip, working, Exc., $40, Item #SH322 SOLD

________________________________________

Sheaffer Feather Touch Set, c1936, gray striated, full size model (one size below oversize), pen is 5 1/2 inches closed, both pieces are very clean, original round price sticker still on back of pencil however all the lettering is worn away, Fine firm nib, pencil working and pen is restored, Exc+, $140, Item # SH447 SOLD

____________________________________

Sheaffer Lifetime Balance 1000, c1935, Oversized model, 5 9/16 inches closed, some wear and fine scratches to pocket clip, cap band & lever are clean, perfect grey coloring, smooth firm XF two-tone Lifetime nib, restored, VG+, $240, Item # SH445 SOLD

____________________________________

Sheaffer Gold Filled Pencil, c1930, gothic pattern, working, near full eraser, brassing to edge of crown, 4 1/2 inches, VG, $25, Item # SH321 SOLD

______________________________

Sheaffer Lifetime Balance Pen, c1936, std size model, 4 13/16 inches closed, mild brassing to edges of clip, pen is engraved on the barrel (see 3rd picture from the top) - engraved area filled w/ black wax, beautiful coloring to pearl chips, solid little pen, very smooth firm Fine+ two-tone Lifetime nib, restored, VG+, $65, Item # SH213 SOLD

____________________________________

Sheaffer BCHR #2 size pen, c1918, 3 7/8 inches closed, some mild chatter marks to sides of the GF crown, Fine nib w/ mild flex, restored, Exc, $85, Item # SH211 SOLD

____________________________________

Sheaffer Snorkel, c1955, 5 5/8 inches closed, nib is marked 'F5' meaning Fine 14k two-tone Triumph Lifetime nib, Exc+, restored, $195, Item #SH207 SOLD

_______________________________

Sheaffer BCHR #46 Special, c1915, 5 3/8 inches closed, small nick to end of barrel (see last pic), firm Med #46 Special nib, restored, Exc, $250, Item # SH315 SOLD

____________________________________

Sheaffer Lifetime Balance Pen, c1932, std size model, 5 1/2 inches closed, some brassing to clip ball, smooth firm XF Lifetime nib, restored, Exc, $90, Item # SH443 SOLD

____________________________________

Sheaffer Lifetime Jade Flattop, Oversize model, 5 1/4 inches closed, c1926, user grade pen, very discolored, some mild shrinkage in the cap, clean trim, solid reliable user, restored, smooth Fine firm Lifetime nib, Good, $85, Item # SH200 SOLD

_______________________________

Sheaffer PFM I, c1959, Green, faint original chalk marks still on barrel, Fine nib, restored, NM, $225, Item # SH205 SOLD

______________________________

Sheaffer PFM II, c1959, Burgundy, original chalk marks still on barrel, Med nib, restored, NM, $275, Item # SH204 SOLD

______________________________

Sheaffer Lifetime Balance Pen, c1935, oversize model, 5 9/16 inches closed, very clean pen, vacuum filler, smooth firm Fine Lifetime nib, professionally restored, Exc+, $260, Item #SH208 SOLD

____________________________________

Sheaffer Lifetime Cartridge Pen, c1961, 5 1/8 inches closed, pen will also take a converter (converter is missing), smooth Fine firm nib, working, $35, Item #SH344 SOLD

________________________________________

Sheaffer, c1924, gold filled, 4 5/8 inches closed, exceptionally clean condition, no dings/dents, have never seen this pattern before, note how the lined/knurled areas are so well blended into the main pattern, we were unable to remove the section (through normal restoration techniques) to restore this pen - for me, preserving the undamaged condition outweighs the need to get it open and install a sac - so we are offering it in its original unrestored condition, the writing sample was a result of dipping the nib, unrestored, NM, $500, Item # SH206 SOLD

_________________________________

Sheaffer Lifetime Balance, c1934, 5 3/8 inches closed, full size model (not oversize), clean trim, barrel a bit discolored, smooth firm Fine two-tone Lifetime nib, restored, Exc, $90, Item #SH203 SOLD

________________________________________

Sheaffer Lifetime Skyboy, c1936, Carmine, 5 3/8 inches closed, smooth firm Fine two-tone nib, restored, Exc, $175, Item # SH439 SOLD

____________________________________

Sheaffer Targa Pencil, c1976, gold plate, model 1007, Made in USA, NM, $30, Item # SH440 SOLD

______________________________

Sheaffer's Balance Pencil, Gray & Red veined, c1934, 4 3/4 inches, humpback clip w/ball, working, Exc, $50, Item #SH352 SOLD

________________________________________

 

Sheaffer Autograph PFM III, c1959, black, 14k cap band, smooth Fine nib, unrestored, Exc, $600, Item # SH412 SOLD

______________________________

 

Sheaffer Lifetime, c1936, gray striated, slim model, 5 7/16 inches closed, fairly clean trim, XF firm two-tone 14k nib, restored, Exc, $75 Item # SH442 SOLD

____________________________________

Sheaffer's Tuckaway Pencil, black, c1934, 4 1/4 inches, clean trim, working, Exc, $15, Item #SH442a SOLD

________________________________________

Sheaffer PFM I, c1959, Blue, original price markings on barrel, Med nib, working, Mint, $350, Item # SH435 SOLD

______________________________

Sheaffer Lifetime Balance Pen, c1932, Oversized model, 5 1/2 inches closed, touch of brassing to clip ball, smooth Fine+ Lifetime nib w/med flex (flexible Lifetime nibs are quite rare), restored, VG, $250, Item # SH431 SOLD

____________________________________

Sheaffer, 5-30, c1928, 4 1/2 inches closed, user grade pen, no notable flaws, smooth Fine firm nib, restored, VG, $50, Item #SH404 SOLD

________________________________________

 

Sheaffer, c1928, 4 5/16 inches closed, user grade pen, clip is loose, smooth Fine firm nib, restored, VG, $30, Item #SH422 SOLD

________________________________________

Sheaffer's Pencil, c1920s, oversize model, early jade color, 5 5/16 inches, nearly clean crown, original eraser missing, working, Exc, $35, Item # SH376 SOLD

______________________________

 

Sheaffer Green & Black Lifetime Balance Set, Oversized, c1932, Autograph model (band, clip & nose cone marked 14k), barrels are a bit darker than the caps, bands inscribed 'Wm E. Plortz', 5 1/2 inches closed, XF Lifetime nib, restored, VG+, $295, Item # SH438 SOLD

________________________________

Sheaffer Lifetime Balance, c1931, 5 7/16 inches closed, full size model, some brassing to clip ball - trim is otherwise clean, smooth Med firm nib, restored, Exc, $100, Item #SH426 SOLD

________________________________________

Sheaffer PFM II, c1959, Green, portions of original price markings still on barrel, Broad nib, working, Mint, $295, Item # SH436 SOLD

Sheaffer PFM III, c1959, Green, original price markings on barrel, Med nib, working, Mint, $350, Item # SH434 SOLD

______________________________

Sheaffer, BHR, #2 size r/t pen, c1915, 3 15/16 inches closed, smooth Fine nib w/ med flex, restored, VG+, $60, Item # SH433 SOLD

____________________________________

Sheaffer Stainless Pencil, c1925, smooth pattern, working, near full eraser, needs a good cleaning, 5 1/8 inches, VG, $30, Item # SH340 SOLD

______________________________

 

Sheaffer Lifetime, c1936, brown striated, slim model, 5 1/2 inches closed, two spots of brassing to cap band, smooth firm Fine+ two-tone nib, restored, VG+, $60, Item # SH428 SOLD

____________________________________

Sheaffer Lifetime Flattop, Oversize model, 5 1/4 inches closed, c1927, some brassing to clip ball, smooth firm Medium Lifetime nib, Exc, $140, Item # SH430 SOLD

_______________________________

Sheaffer Flattop, c1930, 5 1/8 inches closed, no notable flaws, smooth Fine+ firm nib, restored, VG, $50, Item #SH406 SOLD

________________________________________

 

Sheaffer Lifetime Sentinel Set, Fiesta Red (please note that the set is slightly more red than the digital photos), GF Trim, c1955, pen is 5 9/16 inches closed, Medium two-tone nib, tags and sticker, boxed, Mint, both pieces working, $275, Item # SH328 SOLD

____________________________________

Sheaffer, 3-25, c1928, 5 1/4 inches closed, user grade pen, crack to cap lip, Fine firm nib, restored, Good, $39, Item #SH413 SOLD

________________________________________