At Five Star Pens, we strive to offer quality vintage and modern pens from numerous manufacturers such as Parker, Waterman's, Conklin, Cross, Wahl Eversharp, Sheaffer's, Montblanc and more.

Sheaffer Lifetime, c1936, brown striated, slim model, 5 1/2 inches closed, minor brassing to cap band, smooth firm Med two-tone nib, restored, VG+, $75, Item # SH429 SOLD

____________________________________

Sheaffer Lifetime Flattop, Oversize model, 5 1/4 inches closed, c1927, some brassing to clip ball & top of clip, cap band about 25% brassed, firm Fine Lifetime nib, VG, $100, Item # SH432 SOLD

_______________________________

Sheaffer Lifetime Balance, c1935, 5 3/8 inches closed, full size model, clean trim, smooth Fine firm nib, restored, Exc+, $95, Item #SH427 SOLD

________________________________________

Sheaffer Grey & Red Veined Balance, c1932, 5 1/2 inches closed, smooth Fine nib w/faint flex, restored, Exc, $75, Item # SH425 SOLD

 ____________________________________

Sheaffer Lifetime, c1934, 4 9/16 inches closed, smooth Fine firm nib, restored, VG, $65, Item #SH421 SOLD

________________________________________

Sheaffer Junior Balance, c1935, 4 3/4 inches closed, visulated section, smooth Fine firm nib, restored, VG, $45, Item #SH419 SOLD

________________________________________

Sheaffer Balance, c1935, 4 3/4 inches closed, user grade pen, wear to cap band, smooth Fine firm nib, restored, VG, $35, Item #SH407 SOLD

________________________________________

 

Sheaffer, 3-25, c1928, 4 5/8 inches closed, no notable flaws, smooth Fine firm nib, restored, VG, $45, Item #SH417 SOLD

________________________________________

 

Sheaffer, 3-25, c1928, 4 3/8 inches closed, Medium nib with just a hint of flex, restored, VG, $40, Item #SH416 SOLD

________________________________________

 

Sheaffer Sterling Pencil (not silver plate), c1925, smooth pattern, full eraser, no dings or dents, flawless crown, working, 5 1/16 inches, Exc+, $150, Item # SH356 SOLD

______________________________

 

Sheaffer Lifetime Balance Pen, c1935, full size model (not oversized), 5 15/32 inches closed, very crisp pen, nib has lost most of its rhodium plating, very smooth firm XF Lifetime nib, professionally restored, Exc+, $225, Item # SH397 SOLD

____________________________________

Sheaffer Lifetime Skyboy, c1936, Carmine, 5 1/2 inches closed, smooth firm Fine two-tone nib, restored, Exc, $175, Item # SH400 SOLD

____________________________________

 

Sheaffer PFM III, c1959, Black, original price markings on barrel, Med nib, working,

Mint, $360, Item # SH336 SOLD

______________________________

Sheaffer, BHR, #2 size pen, c1915, 5 5/16 inches closed, Fine nib w/ med flex, restored, VG+, $95, Item # SH423 SOLD

____________________________________

Sheaffer Lifetime Jade Flattop, Oversize model, 5 5/16 inches closed, c1920s, fair color, restored, smooth Fine nib, VG, $90, Item # SH424 SOLD _______________________________

Sterling Hand-Engraved Sheaffer Ringtop, c1917, 3 7/8 inches closed, smooth Fine Sheaffer #2 nib w/great flex, restored, NM, $135, Item # SH418 SOLD

____________________________________

Sheaffer Green & Black Lifetime Balance, Oversized, c1932, Autograph model (Band & Clip marked 14k), band inscribed, 5 5/8 inches closed, smooth Fine two-tone nib, restored, Exc, $375, Item # SH325 SOLD

____________________________________

Sheaffer Lifetime Balance, c1935, 5 1/4 inches closed, full size model, clean trim, smooth XF firm nib, restored, Exc+, $95, Item #SH414  SOLD

________________________________________

 

Sheaffer BCHR #29 1/2, c1918, 5 1/2 inches closed, rare 14k trim model, I beleive box is original to pen, box marked "Marshall Field & Company Chicago', its a joy to write with this pen, Fine flexible nib, restored, Exc+, $375, Item # SH396 SOLD

____________________________________

 

Sheaffer's Fish Base, c1920s, base measures 4 inches in diameter, heafty base weighing nearly 2 lbs., very clean piece, Exc+, $225, Item #SH357 SOLD

_________________________________________

 

Sheaffer Lifetime Autograph Lever Filling Balance Pen, c1932, 5 3/8 inches closed, std size model, 14kt band and clip, cap band engraved JD Rhoades, smooth firm XF two-tone nib, restored, Exc, $195, Item # SH320 SOLD

____________________________________

Sheaffer's Pencil, c1920s, oversize model, 5 1/4 inches, rim of brassing to crown, one mild ding to edge of crown, extra lead & original eraser, working, VG, $35, Item #SH403 SOLD

______________________________

 

Sheaffer, model 500, c1930s, 5 7/16 inches closed, no flaws, smooth 14k Fine two-tone nib, restored, VG, $75, Item #SH405 SOLD

________________________________________

 

Sheaffer Lifetime Balance Pen, c1932, Oversized model, 5 1/2 inches closed, some brassing to top edge of clip & clip ball, smooth firm Fine Lifetime nib, restored, VG, $160, Item # SH393 SOLD

____________________________________

 

Sheaffer PFM IV, c1959, Burgundy, traces of original price markings on barrel, Med nib, restored, Near Mint, $495, Item # SH398 SOLD

______________________________

 

Sheaffer's Pencil, c1920s, jade, 4 5/8 inches, clean crown, original eraser totally worn, working, Exc, $40, Item # SH402 SOLD

______________________________

 

Sheaffer Triumph 1000 Lifetime Pen, c1945, 5 3/16 inches closed, smooth firm XF two-tone nib, restored, Exc+, $140, Item # SH401 SOLD

____________________________________

 

Sheaffer Lifetime Desk Pen, 7 5/8 tip to tip, c1928, pen is clean but taper is frozen in place, smooth firm XF Lifetime nib, Exc, $45, Item # SH399 SOLD

_______________________________

 

Sheaffer, model 875, c1940s, 5 1/4 inches closed, user grade pen, no flaws except a little roughness to the edges of the lever, smooth 14k Fine firm nib, restored, VG, $50, Item #SH395 SOLD

________________________________________

 

Sheaffer's Golf Pencil, Grey & Red Veined, c1934, working, Exc., $75, Item #SH301 SOLD

________________________________________

Sheaffer's Balance Pencil, Gray & Red veined, c1934, 4 3/4 inches, humpback clip w/ball, working, Exc, $50, Item #SH384 SOLD

________________________________________

 

Sheaffer's Pencil, c1920s, oversize model, 5 5/16 inches, clean crown, original eraser, working, Exc+, $75, Item # SH349 SOLD

______________________________

 



Sheaffer 5-30 Balance, std size, 5 1/4 inches closed, restored, c1930s, some darkening in barrel, Exc condition, Fine nib, $100, Item # SH307 SOLD

_______________________________

Sheaffer Lifetime Combo, c1932, 6 inches closed, rare Lifetime model w/band on the barrel, some brassing to edge of clip ball, a little more brassing to edges of barrel band, pencil working, a couple nicks and some brassing to nose cone, firm Fine Lifetime nib, restored, VG, $225, Item # SH394 SOLD

____________________________________

 

Sterling Hand-Engraved Sheaffer Ringtop, c1917, 4 inches closed, initials on cartouche, F nib, restored, NM, $150, Item # SH313 SOLD

____________________________________

Sheaffer Carmine Red Lifetime Lever Filling Balance Pen, c1934, 5 7/16 inches closed, long slim model, smooth firm Fine two-tone nib, restored, Exc+, $190

Item # SH319 SOLD - SOLD

____________________________________

Vintage Sheaffer Tray, c1920s, 7 inches x 7 1/8 inches x 1 1/4 inches tall, beautiful tan felt, Exc., $195, Item #SH387 SOLD - SOLD

________________________________________

 

Sheaffer PFM III, c1959, Green, original price markings on barrel, Med nib, working, Mint, $375, Item # SH334 SOLD - SOLD

______________________________

Oversize Sheaffer Balance Lifetime, Marine Green, c1935, 5 1/2 inches closed, a little darkening in the cap (see pic), Fine firm two-tone nib, restored, Exc, $275, Item # SH388 SOLD - SOLD

____________________________

 

Oversize Sheaffer Lifetime Balance , Grey & Black marbled, c1935, 5 1/2 inches closed, Fine firm two-tone nib, nib has been strightened at tip, brassing to top edge of cap band, lever a bit more worn than normal, surface condition of pen is excellent, restored, Exc, $550, Item # SH391 SOLD - SOLD

____________________________

 

Sheaffer Lifetime Flattop, Oversize model, 5 5/16 inches closed, c1929, no brassing, smooth medium Lifetime nib, Exc+, $175, Item # SH390 SOLD - SOLD

_______________________________

 

Sheaffer Lifetime Crest 5000, black piston filler, c1946, 5 inches closed, 14k cap and clip (note that the cap is marked 14k just above the engraved name; clip marked at top of clip) clean cap, engraved John Wright MD, smooth firm Fine nib, restored, Exc+, $375, Item # SH385 SOLD - SOLD

____________________________________

 

Sheaffer Lifetime Balance Pen, c1932, Oversized model, 5 3/4 inches closed, some brassing to clip & cap band, exc color, smooth firm Fine Lifetime nib, restored, VG, $295, Item # SH381 SOLD - SOLD

____________________________________

 

Sheaffer LifetimeTriumph  Set, 1000, carmine red, piston filler, c1945, 5 inches closed, box is clean but wont quite close, pencil works great, smooth firm Fine nib, profesionally restored, crisp set, Exc+, $195, Item # SH386 SOLD - SOLD

____________________________________

 

Sheaffer 3-25 Balance, std size, 4 7/16 inches closed, c1930s, beautiful coloring, no brassing, smooth firm Fine+ nib, restored, Exc++, $75, Item # SH383 SOLD - SOLD

_______________________________

 

Sheaffer Targa, c1976, solid Sterling Silver, model 1006, stickered, Made in USA, 14k Fine nib, comes w/original converter & box, working, Mint, $250, Item # SH354 SOLD - SOLD

______________________________

 

Sheaffer's PFM Clip Activated BP Demonstrator, c1959, 5 1/8 inches, flawless piece, working, needs refill, NM, $250, Item #SH353 SOLD - SOLD

________________________________________

 

Sheaffer Lifetime Triumph Snorkel Set, c1955, gold filled caps and barrels, pen is 5 9/16 inches closed, Med two-tone nib, clip tags & box tags, set was $42.50 when new, boxed, Mint, pen fully restored, both pieces working, $395, Item # SH377 SOLD - SOLD

____________________________________

 

Gold Filled Sheaffer, c1924, exceptional condition, no dings/dents, 5 inches closed, smooth flexible Med Sheaffer's #3 Self-Filling nib, restored, NM, $400, Item # SH312 SOLD - SOLD

_________________________________

 

Vintage Sheaffer Tray, c1920s, 7 inches x 7 inches x 1 1/4 inches tall, beautiful tan felt, Exc., $195, Item #SH372 SOLD - SOLD

________________________________________

 

Vintage Sheaffer Tray, c1920s, 7 inches x 7 inches x 1 1/4 inches tall, beautiful light tan felt, Exc., $195, Item #SH371 SOLD - SOLD

________________________________________

 

Sheaffer's Balance Pencil, Gray & Red veined, c1934, 5 1/4 inches, full sz (not oversized), humpback clip w/ball, working, Exc, $55, Item #SH343 SOLD - SOLD

________________________________________

 

Sheaffer's Pencil, c1920s, slim model, 5 1/8 inches, clean crown, original eraser, working, Exc+, $45, Item # SH347 SOLD - SOLD

______________________________

 

Sheaffer 5-30 Flattop, pen and pencil, c1928, perhaps not a set but sold together -slight jade color difference between pen and pencil, flawless Sheaffer's casket box, 5-30 pen measures 5 5/16 closed, firm Medium 5-30 nib, restored, pencil works great, no flaws to either piece, Exc, $195, Item # SH331 SOLD - SOLD

____________________________________

Sheaffer PFM III, c1959, Black, Stub nib, restored, Exc, $295, Item # SH383 SOLD - SOLD

______________________________

 

Sheaffer PFM III, c1959, Burgundy, original price markings on barrel, Med nib, working, Mint, $375, Item # SH335 SOLD - SOLD

______________________________

Sheaffer's Prototype Pencil, c1920s, standard model, 5 1/8 inches, clean crown, original eraser, working, Exc+, $295, Item # SH382  SOLD - SOLD

______________________________

 

Sheaffer Lifetime Desk Pen, jade, 7 3/8 tip to tip, c1928, smooth firm Fine Lifetime nib, excellent coloring, Exc, $80, Item # SH380 SOLD - SOLD

_______________________________

 

Sheaffer Lifetime Desk Pen, blk & pearl, 7 5/8 tip to tip, c1928, smooth firm Fine+ Lifetime nib, excellent coloring, Exc, $80, Item # SH374 SOLD - SOLD

_______________________________

 

Sheaffer Black Lifetime Balance, Oversized, c1935, 5 9/16 inches closed, very smooth Fine Lifetime nib, exc writer, restored, NM, $150, Item # SH379 SOLD - SOLD

____________________________________

 

Sheaffer's Pencil, c1920s, oversize model, blk & prl, 5 1/4 inches, clean crown, original eraser, working, Exc, $75, Item # SH368 SOLD - SOLD

______________________________

 

Sheaffer BHR #5, c1915, 5 11/16 inches closed, Fine+ #5 Self Filling nib with a hint of flex, restored, Exc, $275, Item # SH378 SOLD - SOLD

____________________________________

 

Sheaffer Snorkel, c1955, 5 9/16 inches closed, smooth Fine+ Lifetime nib, Exc, restored, $150, Item # SH375 SOLD - SOLD

_______________________________

 

Sheaffer Carmine Red Lifetime Balance Pen, c1934, 5 1/2 inches closed, model 1000 (meaning it was $10.00 when new), lever filler, full size model (one sz below oversized), smooth firm Fine two-tone nib, restored, Exc, $225, Item # SH370 SOLD - SOLD

____________________________________

 

Sheaffer Lifetime Autograph Flattop Set, c1927, pen measures 5 1/4 closed, 14k trim on clips, cap band, pencil crown, & pencil nose cone (please note that all this trim is stamped 14k), 14k cap band very lightly incribed w/ a script name - no dings to cap band, exceptionally rare fully flexible factory stub Lifetime nib, pen restored, pencil works great and has a flawless crown, set was used but very well cared for, no flaws to either piece, Exc, $575, Item # SH359 SOLD - SOLD

____________________________________

 

Sheaffer Lifetime Flattop, Oversize model, 5 5/16 inches closed, c1929, light brassing to edge of cap band, smooth rare factory stub Lifetime nib, VG, $225, Item # SH360 SOLD - SOLD

_______________________________

 

Sheaffer Lifetime Flattop, Oversize model, 5 5/16 inches closed, lined hard rubber, white dot on top of cap, c1926, brassing to ball of clip, cap band personalized "Russell C. Wiley", smooth Med Lifetime nib, VG+ (better looking than pics), $160, Item # SH366 SOLD - SOLD

_______________________________

 

Gold Filled Sheaffer, c1924, three shallow dings to cap, 5 3/8 inches closed,  F nib, restored, VG, $225, Item # SH309 SOLD - SOLD

_________________________________

Sheaffer Lifetime Autograph Triumph 5000, c1942, 5 1/4 inches closed, the number 5000 means that this pen was $50.00 when new, firm factory broad stub, restored, Exc, $350, Item # SH358 SOLD - SOLD

____________________________________

 

Sheaffer PFM IV, c1959, Black, original price markings on barrel, Med nib, pen has been dipped in ink, working, Mint, $550, Item # SH337 SOLD - SOLD

______________________________

Sheaffer Gray Striated Lifetime Balance, Oversized, c1935, 5 1/2 inches closed, Fine two-tone nib, restored, Exc, $395, Item # SH362 SOLD - SOLD

____________________________________

 

 

Sheaffer Carmine Red Lifetime Lever Filling Balance Pen, c1945, Model #1000 (marked on barrel), 5 3/16 inches closed, smooth firm Fine two-tone Triumph nib, restored, Exc, $140, Item # SH365 SOLD - SOLD

____________________________________

 

Sheaffer PFM V, Gray, teeny micro ding to otherwise flawless cap, smooth Fine nib, working, c1950s, Exc., $425, Item # SH330 SOLD - SOLD

________________________________________

Sheaffer's Oversize Balance Pencil, c1935, 5 1/2 inches, flat-ball clip, some brassing to edge of ball, working, Exc, $80, Item #SH367 SOLD - SOLD

________________________________________

 

Sheaffer 3-25 Flattop, c1928, 5 3/8 inches closed, XF 3-25 nib, restored, Exc,

$195, Item # SH324 SOLD - SOLD

____________________________________

Sheaffer BHR #34, c1915, 5 3/8 inches closed, some mild oxidation, Fine nib w/med flex, restored, VG, $100, Item # SH363 SOLD - SOLD

____________________________________

 

Sheaffer Red Carmine Lifetime Balance, Oversized, c1935, 5 1/2 inches closed, smooth Fine two-tone nib, restored, VG, $450, Item # SH355 SOLD - SOLD ____________________________________

 

Oversize Sheaffer Gray & Red Veined Lifetime Balance, c1932, 5 1/2 inches closed, smooth Med two-tone nib, restored, Exc, $550, Item # SH314 SOLD - SOLD ____________________________________

Sheaffer's Pencil, c1920s, 14k crown, 14k clip, and 14k nose cone, 4 9/16 inches, dings to crown, cannot remove crown, working, VG, $80, Item # SH351 SOLD - SOLD ______________________________

 

Sheaffer PFM III, c1959, Green, original price markings on barrel, Made in Australia (marking on cap & nib), M nib, working, Mint, $375, Item # SH346 SOLD - SOLD ______________________________

 

 

Sheaffer Triumph, Lifetime, Carmine Red, c1942, 5 1/4 inches closed, Vacuum Filler, perfect barrel transparency, firm F two-tone nib, crisp pen, unrestored, NM, $125, Item # SH327    SOLD - SOLD

____________________________________

Sterling Sheaffer Filigree, c1918, 5 1/4 inches closed, engraved, smooth fully flexible M nib, restored, Exc, $795, Item # SH308 SOLD - SOLD

____________________________________

Sheaffer Red & Gray Veined Lifetime Balance, c1932, 4 13/16 inches closed, two closed stable cracks on back side of cap - hard to see but there, smooth F two-tone nib, restored, Exc, $75, Item # SH310 SOLD - SOLD

____________________________________

Sheaffer Balance, smallest size, 4 1/8 inches closed, restored, c1930s, Exc condition, Fine Nib, $95, Item # SH302 SOLD - SOLD

________________________________________

Sheaffer Lifetime Jade Flattop, Oversize model, 5 5/16 inches closed, c1920s, exceptionally clean color, restored, smooth Fine nib, Exc+, $295, Item # SH317 SOLD - SOLD

_______________________________

Sheaffer 3-25 Flattop, c1928, 4 7/16 inches closed, smooth Fine firm nib, restored,

Exc, $50, Item #SH341 SOLD - SOLD

________________________________________

 

Sheaffer PFM IV Set, c1959, Gray, original price markings on barrels (note light chalk marks on pencil barrel), Med nib, working, Mint, $795, Item # SH345 SOLD - SOLD

______________________________

 

Vintage Sheaffer Tray, c1920, Exc. $195 (two avail)

Item # SH304 SOLD - SOLD

________________________________________

Vintage Sheaffer Tray, c1920s, beautiful gray felt, Exc., $195

Item #SH305 SOLD - SOLD

________________________________________

Sheaffer's Balance Pencil, Marine Green Radite, c1937, 5 1/2 inches, Oversized model, working, Exc, $70, Item #SH344 SOLD - SOLD

________________________________________

 

Sheaffer's Pencil, blk & pearl, c1920s, slim model, 4 9/16 inches, clean crown, original eraser, working, Exc++, $45, Item # SH350 SOLD - SOLD

______________________________

 

Sheaffer's Pencil, c1920s, oversize model, 5 5/16 inches, clean crown, large deco initials engraved on back of barrel, original eraser, working, Exc+, $60, Item # SH348 SOLD - SOLD

______________________________

 

Sheaffer 5-30 Balance, c1930s, std size, 5 3/8 inches closed, near perfect color, Exc condition, smooth factory stub w/faint flex, restored, $225, Item # SH332 SOLD - SOLD

______________________________

Sheaffer Carmine Red Lifetime Lever Filling Balance Pen, c1945, seldom seen model, 5 1/4 inches closed, flawless GF lined cap, light brassing to clip edges, smooth firm Fine two-tone Triumph nib, restored, Exc+, $195

Item # SH326 SOLD - SOLD

____________________________________

Sheaffer PFM IV, c1959, Burgundy, original price markings on barrel, Fine nib, working,

Mint, $575, Item # SH342 SOLD - SOLD

______________________________

 

Sheaffer Black Hard Ringtop, c1915, 4 7/16 inches closed, early Sheaffer'S imprint,

lip crack (see pic), smooth, Fine, fully flexible #3 Self-Filling nib, restored, VG, $50

Item # SH339 SOLD - SOLD

____________________________________

 

Oversized Sheaffer Secretary, c1922, BCHR, 5 3/8 inches closed, restored, light overall oxidation, Fine Secretary nib, Exc., $500

Item #SH306 SOLD - SOLD

________________________________________

Sheaffer BCHR 46 Special, c1915, 5 3/8 inches closed, firm F nib, restored, Exc, $275

Item # SH311 SOLD - SOLD

____________________________________

Oversize Sheaffer Balance Lifetime w/ mother of pearl chips, c1935, 5 1/2 inches closed, heat stamped name on barrel, XF two-tone nib, restored, Exc++, $475

Item # SH333 SOLD - SOLD

Sheaffer Carmine Red Lifetime Lever Filling Balance Pen, c1934, 5 7/16 inches closed, long slim model, smooth firm Fine+ two-tone nib, restored, Exc+, $150

Item # SH329 SOLD - SOLD

____________________________________

Sheaffer Green & Black Lifetime Balance, c1932, 4 3/4 inches closed, XF Needle Point Firm Lifetime nib, unrestored, Exc+, $125

Item # SH323 SOLD - SOLD

____________________________________

 

Sheaffer PFM III, Green, smooth Fine nib, working, c1950s, Exc., $275

Item # SH303 SOLD - SOLD

________________________________________

Sheaffer Gold Filled Filigree, c1917, 4 inches closed, smooth flexible Med Sheaffer's #2 Self Filling nib, restored, Exc, $180

Item # SH318 SOLD - SOLD

____________________________________

Oversize Sheaffer Balance Lifetime w/ mother of pearl chips, c1935, 5 1/2 inches closed, F two-tone nib, restored, Exc, $475 SOLD - SOLD

Item # SH316

____________________________________